Mar 15, 2008

What It Might Be Like to Live in Viriconium

“What would it be really like to live in the world of…?” is an inappropriate question, a category error.

Pretentiousness at its best. Who is M. John Harrison to tell me what questions I will and will not ask about fiction? He writes:

Like all books, Viriconium is just some words. There is no place, no society, no dependable furniture to “make real.”

Well, of course! That’s why it’s a hypotethical: what would it be like? The thesis Harrison puts forth is that you shouldn’t try to infer how the society a work of fiction, and especially a work of speculative fiction describes would work. Thanks for the advice, but no, I think I’ll ask exactly the questions I want to ask about a work of fiction, M. John Harrison be damned.

About
Daily Meh is written and edited by Simen (contact me). I live in Norway. This blog is about whatever interests me. Here are some of my favorite posts from the archives. You can subscribe via RSS.